THE RETURNERS starts out strong as Will, a boy who has lost his mother and is struggling to cope with his abusive father, starts succumbing to his increasing paranoia that he is being followed.
The ‘freaks’ as he calls them, watch him with expectant, hooded gazes and seem to know more about Will than they let on. Each night Will has horribly vivid nightmares of historical torture and human destruction and during the day he suffers from regular migraines.
However the story takes a disappointing turn about half way through the book when Will discovers who he really is. Gemma Malley’s first two novels, THE DECLARATION and THE RESISTANCE were incredibly well thought out, and a shining example of speculative fiction at its best. While The Returners does display the same imagination and probing nature, it seems all too short a novel to be able to deal with the many issues that are raised. Aside from the storyline of the returners themselves, there was the compelling arc of a local murder sparking already building racial tensions in the UK, and then the more personal story of Will’s own relationships with those around him, his father, teachers and friends, and his feelings about his mother’s death. Each of these plot lines started out strong but seemed to reach the middle where they ran out of steam and settled for a positive message at the end rather than building to the unsettling climax that I had anticipated.
This said, I continue to be enthralled with Malley’s questioning mind, and if anything, my biggest complaint with this book is that it is not long enough to be truly spectacular. It will be an excellent talking point for young adults, and will certainly spark some fiery debate.
ANONYMITY JONES has not been an easy book for me to review because it took me so long to decide whether or not I enjoyed it. So I stewed on it for a while, and realized that I loved the book, but that I didn’t always love the character. And I loved that.
After all, who can honestly say that they were everything they wanted to be in high school? And who honestly likes any teenage girl all of the time? The truth is, that in high school everything is heightened. Every romance is THE biggest, every heartbreak is the MOST crushing, and every friendship is the deepest that you could imagine. And if going through that emotional rollercoaster day after day was everything that people wanted for their lives, then everything after high school would probably come as a pale disappointment.
James Roy has created a character that you don’t always like, who makes decisions that you don’t always understand. And that’s exactly what makes Anonymity Jones so amazing. Because she actually could be your best friend, your big sister or your next door neighbor. And she’s funny. Sharp tongued and witty, Anonymity could easily be the person that you thought you wanted to be at school. But that doesn’t make her perfect. It does make her honest, and raw and REAL. And who wouldn’t want to read about someone like that?
A post script. When you have read the book, closely, make your choice about Sam. Dog or Boy? LOOK LEFT AND VOTE NOW!
The Little Bookroom opened its doors to the public on Friday the 13th October, 1960, the first bookstore in Australia to stock only children's books.
The shop is named for a collection of stories by Eleanor Farjeon who wrote "I am proud and happy to know you've chosen the title of my book for the title of your Bookshop in the City my Father first set foot in the 1850s when he emigrated to Australia as a boy of 16. The stories he told me of his arrival in Melbourne have always made it seem to be one of 'my' cities. Thankyou for giving me a home in it".
The Little Bookroom's logo also comes from its award-winning namesake - it is a treasured example of Edward Ardizzone's ink illustration.
The Little Bookroom is now located at 759 Nicholson St with Albert’s original shelves, and has a city outpost at 5 Degraves St, Melbourne (doors opened in Feb 2011).